͵ÅÄ͵¿ú

Life in the Lab

Illuminating leadership during crisis

Melissa Vaught
July 22, 2020

Crisis has a way of revealing things about leaders, from the lab manager to the top of the institution. In times of uncertainty, the spotlight is on them. How they react and communicate decisions (or don’t), while influenced by organizational policy and culture, tells us something about their values.

Vaught-Leadership-445x223.jpg

The charismatic, confident leader might make for a good business profile or biography, but contrary to popular caricatures, these characteristics don’t make an excellent leader. Literally volumes have been written to describe styles, types and characteristics of leaders good, bad and great. In this moment, I find myself looking most for the following three traits.

Transparency

Knowledge is power, yet sometimes managers hoard it, claiming that it protects employees. They don’t want an employee thinking about budget constraints or the stability of their position. In the lab, this is framed as allowing members to focus on the science. At other times, managers lack information or clarity and, worried that transparency will undermine their authority, say something with certainty they cannot possibly have or say nothing at all.

These situations readily can backfire: In the absence of a compelling narrative, people willcreate their own. Leaders recognize the importance of transparency, That’s not to say leaders disclose everythingto everyone. No work ever would get done that way, and there’s some information that a leader cannot or should not disclose (examples include legal proceedings and confidential matters). Transparency is more than a data dump. It includes contextualization: how we got the information, what it means for us, what assumptions have been made, how the organization is responding. Sharing the what and why of the things that affect your team builds trust, which can .

Humility

In my own experience, the culture of academic science often pushes for an appearance of confidence, even to the point of arrogance. We are taught to pick apart every result presented to us, to question every claim and to defend vociferously our own work and point of view. As our scientific training advances, a tension builds between the joy of learning and openness and the demand to be self-assured and right. We are pushed to promote the importance and impact of our work and field and, implicitly or explicitly, to elevate its value — or at least the perception of its value — above others.

It should come as no surprise, then, that transparency can feel risky or at the very least uncomfortable, in part because it may require admitting weaknesses, deficiencies, even mistakes. Humility requires that we recognize failures and flaws. But it also frees us from perfection. Humility empowers us to say, “I don’t know.” It keeps us from buying into our own hype. We can . They may even help us with those questions we don’t have answers for yet. It comes easier to some than others, but just like any other skill, through honestly assessing what we don’t know, genuinely listening to weird ideas and nourishing our curiosity.

Compassion

Leadership requires connection, and we often turn to empathy to relate to others. But . It is short-lived and exhausting and can even be paralyzing. It can with critical feedback (Kim Scott in “Radical Candor” refers to this as “ruinous empathy”). Perhaps most importantly, we tend to empathize most with those who look like us, so empathy can .

That doesn’t remove a place for care in leadership. Now more than ever, the . Care does not diminish the effectiveness of leadership. Compassionate leaders can transform organizations for their employees. Kim Scott suggests, from her experience and review of research, that individuals and organizations excel when managers directly challenge their employees while also caring deeply — or practicing “radical candor.” Imagining how someone must be feeling doesn’t spur action, but for their teams. They make space for others and seek to lead through influence rather than authority.

Maybe these aren’t the top characteristics that come to mind when you think of leaders. Yet these elements represent grounding principles from which other powerful qualities flow — clarity, flexibility, mindful presence, accountability and thoughtful delegation, among others. Crisis shines a light on the difference between management and leadership, and it’s time to broaden our vision of what leadership can be.

Enjoy reading ASBMB Today?

Become a member to receive the print edition four times a year and the digital edition weekly.

Learn more
Melissa Vaught

Melissa Vaught is the director of research development for the Institute of Translational Health Science at the University of Washington (views expressed here are her own). In Seattle, you might spot her running on the roads or the trails.

Featured jobs

from the

Get the latest from ASBMB Today

Enter your email address, and we’ll send you a weekly email with recent articles, interviews and more.

Latest in Careers

Careers highlights or most popular articles

Upcoming opportunities
Announcement

Upcoming opportunities

Nov. 21, 2024

Just added: Register for ASBMB's virtual session on thriving in challenging academic or work environments.

Who decides when a grad student graduates?
Training

Who decides when a grad student graduates?

Nov. 15, 2024

Ph.D. programs often don’t have a set timeline. Students continue with their research until their thesis is done, which is where variability comes into play.

Upcoming opportunities
Announcement

Upcoming opportunities

Nov. 14, 2024

Submit an abstract for ASBMB's meeting on ferroptosis!

Join the pioneers of ferroptosis at cell death conference
In-person Conference

Join the pioneers of ferroptosis at cell death conference

Nov. 13, 2024

Meet Brent Stockwell, Xuejun Jiang and Jin Ye — the co-chairs of the ASBMB’s 2025 meeting on metabolic cross talk and biochemical homeostasis research.

A brief history of the performance review
Jobs

A brief history of the performance review

Nov. 8, 2024

Performance reviews are a widely accepted practice across all industries — including pharma and biotech. Where did the practice come from, and why do companies continue to require them?

Upcoming opportunities
Announcement

Upcoming opportunities

Nov. 7, 2024

Save the date for ASBMB's in-person conferences on gene expression and O-GlcNAcylation in health and disease.