偷拍偷窥

It’s been a great year for RNA biologists: First the was awarded to Emmanuelle Charpentier and Jennifer Doudna for the development of CRISPR–Cas9 as a technology for genome editing, and then came to our rescue against the COVID-19 pandemic.

Ryan Flynn, now an RNA biologist at Harvard University and Boston Children’s Hospital, was a postdoc in Carolyn Bertozzi’s lab when he identified glycoRNA on a cell’s surface.

Carolyn Bertozzi, a professor of chemistry at Stanford University and the study’s senior author, said of the breakthrough, “All of a sudden, you have to rewrite all the textbooks.”

What more is there to say about this biomolecule to mark the fourth anniversary of RNA Day? My eureka moment came when I saw in the journal Cell that describes how RNA can be glycosylated and how these sugar-coated RNA molecules, or glycoRNAs, present themselves on a cell’s surface, suggesting they play a role in immune signaling.

, a professor of chemistry at Stanford University and the study’s senior author, described the breakthrough: “All of a sudden, you have to rewrite all the textbooks, because we’re dealing with a cell surface that has not just glycoproteins and glycolipids, but also glycoRNA.”

, the lead author and an RNA biologist at Harvard University and Boston Children’s Hospital, explained the discovery in simple terms. “If your body is made up of cells, and the cells need to communicate to each other, maybe before this work, the idea was that the cell surface has two hands,” he said. “Our work says that now there are three hands, and we don’t know what that third hand is doing. But there’s a new hand, and it’s out there.” 

A bumpy and unexpected start 

Flynn joined Bertozzi’s lab as a postdoctoral researcher in 2017, wanting to expand his expertise from RNA to another biopolymer: glycans and carbohydrates. He had an interesting hypothesis regarding the possibility for cytosolic glycosylation of RNA with O-linked beta-N-acetylglucosamine, or O-GlcNAc. He thought this might work because the protein O-GlcNAc transferase, or OGT, responsible for glycosylation, also has an RNA-binding domain. 

This is where Bertozzi’s expertise in bio-orthogonal chemistry played an important role. Flynn was using bio-orthogonally functionalized sugars that could be fed to cells to look for sugars attached to RNAs. These functional sugars then could click an affinity probe that allowed him to visualize, enrich and then separate out the labeled molecules. 

Flynn set out to look for RNAs that were labeled with the glycans used in that cytosolic glycosylation pathway. He did not find them. 

“After nine months of rigorous experiments and controls after controls, I realized that I didn’t know what I had found,” Flynn said. “I asked myself, ‘What do I know about all the experiments I did?’ And I couldn’t come up with any specific conclusions.” 

Going through the blots, however, he realized that the only consistency across every cell type tested was the presence of an RNA-sensitive single band that he observed on treatment with N-azidoacetylmannosamine, orManNAz, a functionally labeled precursor for a group of glycans known for their role in glycosylating secretory and cell surface proteins and lipids. 

“And that’s where the big question mark and the head scratching started, because in a way ManNAz was a negative control,” Bertozzi said. “There was no reason to believe that RNA could get modified with the kinds of sugars that secreted and cell surface glycoproteins get labeled with, because there’s no framework by which RNA accesses the secretory pathway.”

When Flynn sequenced the RNAs, they all fell into the category of small noncoding RNAs, including types such as transfer, small nuclear and Y RNAs — all structured and highly conserved noncoding RNAs. Researchers do not understand yet the cellular functions of Y RNAs, but they have been identified as autoantigens in a number of autoimmune diseases. 

Courtesy of Ryan Flynn and Carolyn Bertozzi

Researchers have long known that glycolipids and glycoproteins are present on the cell surface. Work in the Bertozzi lab revealed what Ryan Flynn describes as the “third hand”: glycoRNA.

GlycoRNAs, cell surface biology and immune signaling 

So where are these RNA present, and what is their function? The team found that the amount of glycoRNA decreases by more than 50% after an hour of incubation with the sialidase, suggesting that more than half of a cell’s glycoRNA is present on its outer membrane.

“I think the position of things often either controls or infers their function,” Flynn said. “And so, if it’s on the cell surface, it really starts to help to fill out the black boxes, and you can begin to design new experiments.” 

He noticed that the glycan structures associated with these small RNAs are highly branched and are dominated with sialic acid sugars as capping groups on these branches. This triggered a connection; the Bertozzi lab already was studying a family of sialoglycan binding receptors that are known to be immune modulatory — the Siglec family.

What if glycoRNAs could serve as biological ligands for members of the Siglec family? Flynn tested whether the binding of Siglecs’ receptors to cells was blocked by or inhibited by treatment with RNAse. While most of the Siglecs’ receptor bindings were unaffected, the binding of two, Siglec-11 and Siglec-14, dropped considerably.

“It’s not only that Ryan discovered that there’s this new kind of molecule, but there’s a whole new kind of pathway to produce this kind of molecule that is not understood,” Bertozzi said. “And once again, we are humbled by how little we know about biology.”

What’s next for glycoRNAs?

“It’s funny how things flip,” Bertozzi said. “Early in this project, I was skeptical and wary. I think Ryan was duly skeptical and wary but also intrigued and persistent. And we knew that for us to convince the world that we really had discovered a new molecule was going to be hard. But once the paper got published, I’ve been really amazed at the response to it.” 

The ManNAz bio-orthogonal labeling method can’t be applied easily to preserved human tissue samples or patient samples — a major limitation of the study. Scientists will need to develop other glycan labeling strategies to detect natural, unlabeled RNA–glycan conjugates.

Going back to his earlier analogy, Flynn said, “What we know is that the third hand might look like the first two hands but has different properties. Maybe it’s a bigger hand, or it’s stronger or weaker. But there’s a third hand, and it’s able to do something. And so then the question is why do the cells need it? How is it made? Where is it made? How many of the cells have three hands? And does that change in disease? And that’s where we are now.”